top of page

In-Service Withdrawals: Benefits You May Not Know

In-service withdrawals refer to the opportunity to take a distribution from your workplace retirement plan, such as a 401(k) or 403(b), while you are still employed and contributing to the plan. This financial strategy can provide benefits and offer a flexibility that is often overlooked. Understanding the nature, implications, and potential benefits of in-service withdrawals can empower employees to take control of their retirement planning in new ways, maximizing the benefits of their retirement savings.


In This Insight


Understanding In-Service Withdrawals

In-Service Withdrawals are withdrawals that one can make from a 401(k) or another similar retirement plan, whilst they are still employed. The key here is that these withdrawals can be made without waiting for a triggering event such as reaching the age of 59.5, retiring, or leaving an employer. This unique feature makes in-service withdrawals an important tool for managing retirement finances for those still in their working years. Knowing the different circumstances under which an in-service withdrawal might be applicable is quite beneficial. In-service withdrawals from retirement plans come in two types: hardship and non-hardship withdrawals.


  • Hardship withdrawals are allowed under certain circumstances such as immediate and heavy financial need, and they must be limited to the amount necessary to satisfy that need. These withdrawals are typically subject to taxes and penalties.

  • Non-hardship withdrawals may be available depending on the plan's rules and typically do not require an immediate financial need. They offer more flexibility, allowing for reinvestment in different options and potentially avoiding taxes and penalties if directly rolled over to an IRA or another qualified plan.

If you're considering an in-service, non-hardship withdrawal, it's possible to reinvest these funds into a wider array of investment options that align with your financial goals. It's important to directly transfer these funds to an IRA or another qualified plan without physically receiving the funds yourself. This direct rollover approach helps in avoiding the withholding of income tax on the withdrawn amount.


Understanding and properly managing in-service withdrawals from a 401(k) can enhance flexibility in retirement funding, ensuring penalties and tax implications are minimized.

Eligibility for In-Service Withdrawals

For most employer-sponsored retirement plans such as 401(k), 403(b), and 457 plans, the age stipulated for in-service withdrawals is 59½ years. Additionally, there is a rule commonly known as the Rule of 55, which applies to individuals who leave their jobs in or after the year they turn 55 and wish to take a withdrawal from that employer's retirement plan tax-free. Overlooking these age requirements could result in substantial tax penalties. However, the fulfillment of age-related criteria doesn't automatically guarantee eligibility. The provisions and guidelines that govern your specific retirement plan heavily influence your capacity to execute an in-service withdrawal. Certain plans provide access to hardship in-service withdrawals. These withdrawals are if the participant experiences an immediate and heavy financial need, defined by the IRS. The plan might require documentation of this hardship, ensuring that the funds withdrawn are used for that specific purpose ensuring that in-service withdrawals don't compromise your financial security in retirement. Special conditions also exist for certain types of retirement plans. One such example is a pension plan, where in most cases, in-service withdrawals aren't permissible until the participant reaches normal retirement age, as dictated by the plan. The particularities of the eligibility requirements underline the importance of understanding your plan provisions comprehensively. Before considering in-service withdrawals, consult with a financial advisor or the plan administrator to determine your eligibility and understand the potential tax implications fully.


If you're directly rolling the retirement plan assets into another qualified retirement account, eligibility simply depends on your plan sponsor. If the plan sponsor allows for non-hardship in-service withdraws, then you would be eligible for a direct rollover into a qualified account.


Achieving eligibility for in-service withdrawals from a retirement plan involves navigating a complex intersection of age requirements, plan-specific guidelines, and potential tax implications.

Tax Impact of In-Service Withdrawals

If an individual makes such a withdrawal before the age of 59 and a half, a 10% early withdrawal penalty tax might apply, on top of regular income taxes due. As such, the tax impact could be somewhat significant, and the net withdrawal amount could be substantially smaller than initially anticipated. While the tax impact of in-service withdrawals can be punitive for younger individuals, those over the age of 59 and a half may be in a different situation. At this age, the 10% early withdrawal penalty tax no longer applies, leaving only the regular income tax due on the withdrawn funds. For those in lower tax brackets, this may not be an overly burdensome tax bill. However, individuals in higher tax brackets should give careful consideration to the potential tax implications, as the withdrawal could cause a significant increase in their total tax liability for the year. One thing that is also worth noting is the role of tax diversification in the context of in-service withdrawals. If one has various types of investment accounts, the tax impact of a withdrawal may differ from one account to the other. For instance, in-service withdrawals from a Roth IRA or a Roth 401(k) generally have no tax due at all, provided certain conditions are met. On the other hand, withdrawals from a traditional IRA or a 401(k) are subject to regular income tax. Hence, having a tax-diversified portfolio could provide individuals with more flexibility and control over the timing and amount of their tax payments.


Understanding the tax implications of in-service withdrawals from retirement plans can lead to better financial decisions and potentially minimize tax liabilities.

Can I continue to contribute to my Employer Plan after an In-service Withdrawal?

Yes, you can generally continue to contribute to your employer's plan after making an in-service withdrawal. However, it's important to note that specific rules can vary depending on your employer's plan policies. Some plans may have certain restrictions or requirements following an in-service withdrawal, so it's advisable to review your plan's details or consult with your plan administrator for specific guidance related to your situation. This will ensure you're fully informed about any impact on your future contributions or benefits.


Advantages and Disadvantages of In-Service Withdrawals

In-service withdrawals, while still actively employed, offer significant benefits. One of the main advantages is the ability to gain access to retirement funds at a younger age, without early withdrawal penalties typically associated with such actions.


For someone facing heavy debt or a significant financial burden, such a provision can be a lifeline. Moreover, some individuals might prefer to take the distribution for strategic investment purposes. For instance, they might want to roll these funds into an IRA that offers a wider array of investment opportunities compared to limited employer-sponsored plan options. Despite the apparent benefits, in-service withdrawals also come with disadvantages that you must bear in mind. One such downside is that pulling out funds from your retirement plan could potentially diminish your retirement savings. Since the funds withdrawn are not in the account, they cannot grow tax-free, thereby reducing your nest egg's overall value. Additionally, withdrawals could incur income tax. Although the penalties for early withdrawal are circumvented, the income tax on withdrawals could still represent a significant cost. Lastly, it's important to understand that the in-service withdrawal option isn't universally available. Its availability largely depends on the plan provisions outlined by employers. Different employers may have different rules regarding the age at which in-service withdrawals can be made and for what reasons. This lack of standardization makes it crucial for members to carefully review their plan guidelines and consult with a financial advisor before pursuing this avenue. Financial institutions also often require proof of hardship before allowing these types of withdrawals.

In-service withdrawals from retirement funds, while still employed, provide early access to your savings without penalties, yet could diminish the overall retirement savings value and possibly incur income tax.

Schedule a Free Consultation with Selective

Maximizing the value of your wealth is a complex task that requires expertise across a variety of disciplines. Schedule a free consultation with an advisor that provides comprehensive wealth management, which includes financial planning, investment management, tax strategies, estate planning, and insurance services. Schedule a free consultation today.


Final Thoughts

In-service withdrawals can be an effective financial tool that offers potential benefits and flexibility if closely managed. By understanding the ins and outs of this mechanism, including one's eligibility, its varied types, and the tax implications thereof, individuals can make informed decisions that align with their financial strategy. It is important to weigh potential advantages and disadvantages, including that in-service withdrawals can provide access to retirement funds while still employed, but they might also present tax and retirement savings implications. Familiarity with these aspects can prove highly beneficial for maximizing one's financial preparedness.


Comments


Commenting has been turned off.

​MORE FROM SELECTIVE

​​SUBSCRIBE TO OUR MONTHLY NEWSLETTER

Thanks for submitting!

CATEGORIES

bottom of page