top of page

Dividing Retirement Accounts in Divorce

When confronting a divorce, sorting through financial assets can prove to be a complex process, especially when it comes to splitting retirement accounts. Identifying, evaluating, and dividing these assets is an important step of the divorce proceedings. Because the value in retirement accounts can be among their most significant assets, it's vital to understand the laws governing the division of these accounts to ensure an equitable distribution.


In This Insight


Understanding Retirement Accounts: Types and Importance

Understanding the different types of retirement accounts and their importance is an important aspect of divorce proceedings, particularly when it comes to asset division. Broadly speaking, retirement accounts can be divided into two categories: defined contribution plans and defined benefit plans. Defined contribution plans include 401(k)s, 403(b)s, and IRAs.


These plans are based on the amount of money you contribute during your working years. Defined benefit plans, on the other hand, are employer-sponsored pensions that provide a specific payout upon retirement, regardless of the contribution amount. Defined contribution plans like 401(k)s and IRAs are often the focus when dividing retirement assets in a divorce, mostly because they are the most common types of retirement accounts. These accounts are significant because they often represent a significant portion of a couple's wealth. When a marriage ends, these assets become a focal point in the financial settlement. Each spouse has a legally justified interest in these accounts because the funds were accrued during the marriage, making them marital property. Defined benefit plans, or pensions, may not be as frequently encountered as defined contribution plans, but they are equally important in divorce proceedings. Unlike defined contribution plans, the value of a pension isn't clear until the employee retires or chooses to take the cash value. This creates a challenge when dividing this type of account during a divorce. However, it is crucial not to overlook or undervalue this kind of retirement asset. A financial advisor or an attorney with expertise in matrimonial law can help ensure that a fair and equitable division of these assets takes place.

Understanding and correctly valuing both defined contribution and defined benefit retirement accounts is vital for an equitable division of assets in divorce proceedings.

The Impact of Divorce on Retirement Accounts

Divorce can significantly affect one's retirement plans. This is because, in many jurisdictions, retirement accounts are considered marital property. Provided both parties contributed to the fund throughout the union, each spouse is entitled to a fair share of the account. The division may lead to a substantial decrease in the expected retirement savings, directly influencing the quality of life post-retirement. Therefore, it's essential to thoroughly evaluate the potential financial consequences of such divisions during the divorce process. There's also another vital factor to consider: tax implications. The funds in retirement accounts grow on a tax-deferred basis. Therefore, there can be substantial tax penalties if these accounts are improperly divided during a divorce. One might have to pay standard income taxes on the money received, or there may be additional early withdrawal penalties if one is below the age-appropriate thresholds. Understanding these implications is critical to minimize unexpected tax burdens after the divorce.


Additionally, a divorce is a rare time that allows you early access to your 401(k) or IRA without a tax penalty if your spouse is awarded part of your account.

One must also consider the long-term impact on retirement income, especially in the case of pensions. After all, pensions are not standard savings accounts nor investments, they are periodic payments one is entitled to receive after reaching a certain age. With a divorce, the court may divide the pension benefits, affecting the projected income in retirement. The impacted individual may need to compensate for this lost income by increasing their savings rate or considering other investment options post-divorce.


Divorce can significantly impact retirement savings and pensions due to asset division and potential tax penalties, making it critical to understand these consequences during the divorce process.

Legal Considerations When Splitting Retirement Accounts in Divorce

Legal regulations can significantly affect the division of retirement accounts during a divorce. Both traditional and Roth IRAs are often divided using a process known as "transfer incident to divorce." This process allows the funds to move as a non-taxable transaction, allowing either party to be able to maintain the tax benefits. Incorrectly splitting these types of retirement accounts could lead to a taxable distribution being recognized, potentially causing an additional 10% penalty for early distribution. Hence, it is crucial to understand and abide by the legal procedures in place to protect one's financial assets and avoid any unexpected tax liabilities. When dealing with employer-sponsored retirement accounts such as a 401(k) or 403(b) plans, a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO) is necessary. This legal document, issued by a court or state agency, indicates that a person other than the employee, usually an ex-spouse, has the right to receive a portion of the benefits of the retirement account. A QDRO provides specific details about the amount to be paid, how the payment should be calculated, and when the payment should be made. Absent a QDRO, an early withdrawal from the account could result in penalties and immediate tax liabilities. Another pivotal legal consideration revolves around determining the valuations and growth of retirement accounts. These accounts are usually divided as marital property, requiring an agreement upon the value at a certain date, usually the date of separation. Future growth of these accounts can also play a significant legal role during divorce proceedings. Spouses have different options such as splitting the assets on the date of division or sharing the future growth and risk. However, the complexity surrounding the valuation of these accounts and the associated legal work required to calculate the equitable distribution often necessitates the need for a specialized attorney or financial professional. Thus, ensuring that the division is legal, fair, and accurate.


In a divorce, it's important to correctly abide by legal procedures when dividing retirement accounts to maintain tax benefits and avoid penalties, through processes like 'transfer incident to divorce' for IRAs and a Qualified Domestic Relations Order for employer-sponsored plans.

Strategies for Dividing Retirement Assets

A prevalent strategy for dividing retirement assets is through a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO). Such a decree enables the allocation of a portion of one spouse's retirement account to the other spouse without triggering any tax responsibilities. This method addresses the complex intertwining of tax considerations and equitable distribution. A QDRO is crucial, especially in situations where substantial amounts of money in retirement accounts are involved. Engaging in offsetting assets is another possibility for dividing retirement assets in a divorce. This method allows one spouse to keep the retirement account intact, while the other spouse receives a marital asset of equal worth, such as the marital home. This strategy can simplify asset division and avoid potential tax implications. However, it is essential to ensure equitable distribution, which might require additional legal expertise and careful financial analysis to ascertain the true value of assets.


Tax Consequences of Dividing Retirement Accounts in Divorce

The division of retirement accounts in a divorce proceeding brings with it significant tax implications that both parties must carefully consider. The type of retirement account determines the tax rules that apply. For example, if dividing a 401k or similar employer-sponsored retirement plan, the distribution of these assets could potentially trigger an immediate tax liability. However, with proper planning, and using a 'Qualified Domestic Relations Order' (QDRO), the transferring spouse can avoid currently paying taxes. Under a QDRO, the transfer of retirement funds from one spouse's 401(k) or similar plan to the other spouse's retirement account is tax-free, provided the receiving spouse keeps the funds in the retirement account. QDROs apply only to employer-sponsored plans. Whoever ends up with the funds must pay income tax on the money when it's withdrawn from the retirement account. The timing of this withdrawal and the recipient's tax bracket upon withdrawal can significantly impact the amount of tax due. However, different rules apply when splitting an Individual Retirement Account (IRA). While QDROs do not cover IRAs, a tax-free transfer can be accomplished under the tax code's section 408(d)(6), which allows for the transfer of IRA balances between spouses, under a divorce or separation agreement. The receiving spouse would then be responsible for any taxes when the funds are withdrawn. Missteps, such as not adhering to the stipulated transfer process, could result in unnecessary taxes and penalties. Consequently, a clear understanding of these tax consequences is absolutely crucial to ensure the financial aspects of a divorce are executed in a tax-efficient manner.


Schedule a Free Consultation with Selective

Maximizing the value of your wealth is a complex task that requires expertise across a variety of disciplines. Schedule a free consultation with an advisor that provides comprehensive wealth management, which includes financial planning, investment management, tax strategies, estate planning, and insurance services. Schedule a free consultation today.


Final Thoughts

The division of retirement assets in a divorce is complex as it involves not only an understanding of the types and significance of such accounts but also the considerable impact of divorce itself on these savings. From legal considerations to strategizing its division, it is crucial to tread carefully to mitigate any potential financial harm. Moreover, the tax consequences of splitting retirement accounts in a divorce are a significant factor, warranting astute attention to detail and professional guidance. This not only safeguards individual financial stability but also ensures a fair distribution of assets.


Comments


Commenting has been turned off.

​MORE FROM SELECTIVE

​​SUBSCRIBE TO OUR MONTHLY NEWSLETTER

Thanks for submitting!

CATEGORIES

bottom of page